Page 2 of 3

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 16 Sep 2013, 21:41
by Mari0Maker
What would you even do if someone posted multiple ratings?

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 16 Sep 2013, 21:49
by idiot9.0
Average them all out to get a score.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 20 Oct 2013, 20:44
by BobTheLawyer
KoopaSchmidt wrote:Super Portal Bros. Mappack.
Please format it like this (I've been wanting to put this map here):

Name: [Drugs] WHEN ARE DRUGS: a journey through drugs and space
Author: Raicuparta
Mod required: No
Progress: Fully finished

Genre: Adventure
Image
Image
Not a big fan of the drug theme, but the art and level design is amazing!

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 20:40
by Gramanaitor
Name: Slih0uette
Author: alesan99

Mod Required: Recommended
Progress: Fully Finished (unfortunately)

Genre: Platform
Image
Image

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 26 Oct 2013, 20:42
by alesan99
Gramanaitor wrote:Progress: Being worked
It's finished.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 14 Dec 2013, 17:35
by Gramanaitor
Since I enjoyed the demo, I'm going to post it here:

Name: Subject 128
Author: OrbitalBlueprint
Mod Required: No
Progress: Being Worked

Image
Image

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 18 Dec 2013, 09:26
by Pixelworker
Gramanaitor wrote: Name: Toadstool Laboratories
Author: OrbitalBlueprint
Mod Required: No
Progress: Being Worked

Image
Image
OrbitalBlueprint changed the mappack's name, it's now called Subject 128. Plus, the screenshots no longer match the actual design (Just saiyin', I assume you have already known that)

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 19 Dec 2013, 09:19
by OrbitalBlueprint
Gramanaitor wrote:Since I enjoyed the demo, I'm going to post it here:

Name: Subject 128
Author: OrbitalBlueprint
Mod Required: No
Progress: Being Worked

Image
Image
You won't believe how much I gasped as I saw this in the main post.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 19 Dec 2013, 16:05
by Villager103
Theme Run
Rating:8/10
By:Villager103

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 19 Dec 2013, 16:48
by OrbitalBlueprint
Villager103 wrote:Theme Run
Rating:8/10
By:Villager103
Even though I've enjoyed that mappack, I'd give it 6/10, since it's kinda short.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 00:45
by Bazvie999
Name: Super Mario Adventures
Author: Bazvie999
Mod required: No
Genre:Adventure
Progress:Being worked
My rating:8
Image

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 00:57
by Qwerbey
(Honestly, I think there should be some rule against posting your own mappacks.)

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 01:14
by HansAgain
QwertymanO07 wrote:(Honestly, I think there should be some rule against posting your own mappacks.)
You're right!

Hey you! Yes, you! The little kid who think his map worth an "8"!
There are mappack that are better than yours and they have less rating (like Lines and Zero Blocks).
I'm not saying that your mappack is bad, but you should wait to someone to rate your map.
I think it's a "6", but i'm not good rating mappack, and i haven't played it.
Play some mappacks and then ask yourself:
"Really my mappack is as good as Abstracta, 0'Brothers or Old Apperture?"
Maybe one day your mappack will be as good as mine.

EDIT: Writing this i noticed that in my mappack says "not updated", and that's a lie.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 15:37
by Villager103
Hans1998 wrote:
QwertymanO07 wrote:(Honestly, I think there should be some rule against posting your own mappacks.)
You're right!

Hey you! Yes, you! The little kid who think his map worth an "8"!
There are mappack that are better than yours and they have less rating (like Lines and Zero Blocks).
I'm not saying that your mappack is bad, but you should wait to someone to rate your map.
I think it's a "6", but i'm not good rating mappack, and i haven't played it.
Play some mappacks and then ask yourself:
"Really my mappack is as good as Abstracta, 0'Brothers or Old Apperture?"
Maybe one day your mappack will be as good as mine.

EDIT: Writing this i noticed that in my mappack says "not updated", and that's a lie.
1.I am 11 so I am NOT little. 5 is little. 11 is not little.

2.Don't be a dick. It IS an 8. No one does stuff for me and when I do stuff for you,(Theme Run, Kaiz0 and a few suggestions) no one likes them. And I have the software to make tilesets so don't even tell me about those.

I am not a bad member. WaryLouka was.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 16:11
by alesan99
Villager103 wrote: 1.I am 11 so I am NOT little. 5 is little. 11 is not little.

2.Don't be a dick. It IS an 8. No one does stuff for me and when I do stuff for you,(Theme Run, Kaiz0 and a few suggestions) no one likes them. And I have the software to make tilesets so don't even tell me about those.

I am not a bad member. WaryLouka was.
1. :|
2. Look, you think it's 8 because you made it. I'm not saying it's horrible but there are mappacks with big (awesome) tilesets with 32 levels that took along time to make that have the rating of 8 and you mappack is no where near as good.

3. You done many things wrong, let me list some. You made a thread about 3D mari0 and you NEVER released it, you didn't even show screenshots. You suggest/ask for way too much stuff EX: my mod thread, a ton of abilities for your villager mod, many other threads you made and you only made these :Theme Run and Kaiz0. When I want something I make it, all I have to do is take some time to do it.

Try to improve, whenever you make posts like this arguments start.

Oh and I think he was talking to Bazvie999 :P

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 19:44
by TurretBot
I think this thread needs to have a new voting system, which doesn't allow people to give their maps extremely high ratings.
Like, you can say maps you like and Hugo can tally how many people said that map for the rating. (Of course this one's probably too simple.)

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 20:10
by HugoBDesigner
Turret Opera wrote:I think this thread needs to have a new voting system, which doesn't allow people to give their maps extremely high ratings.
Like, you can say maps you like and Hugo can tally how many people said that map for the rating. (Of course this one's probably too simple.)
Nah, I think letting people rate a suggested mappack is better. I get the average of all votes and put in the OP. But for now on, people will no longer be able to vote their own mappacks. It's a drastic decision, because there are people that votes their things thinking on other mappacks (me, for example). The same applies to "Mods Guide and Rating".

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 20:34
by HansAgain
Villager103 wrote: 1.I am 11 so I am NOT little. 5 is little. 11 is not little.

2.Don't be a dick. It IS an 8. No one does stuff for me and when I do stuff for you,(Theme Run, Kaiz0 and a few suggestions) no one likes them. And I have the software to make tilesets so don't even tell me about those.

I am not a bad member. WaryLouka was.
0. I was not talking to you, but i should.
1. I'm 15, when i was 11 all my relatives said that i was little.
2. I'm not saying that i don't like them, they are good mappack, but only that, good, no more, no less. An 8 is reserved for great mappack, 7 for very good mappacks, and 6 for good. I didn't rated my mappack as the "Best mappack ever", i put a lot of effort in it, I dedicated a lot of time in it, then someone rated it.
I suggest you to do the same, put effort in your mappack, and then wait to someone to rate it. If that never comes, you don't have to care, it's the best mappack to you, but you don't have to obligate everybody to love your mappack.

3. Nobody said that you are a bad member (at least i didn't), i said that you have to think better the quality of your mappacks. They are still good, but no more than that.
I don't know if i'm doing it right. I think i should stop here.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 20:41
by TurretBot
HugoBDesigner wrote:
Turret Opera wrote:I think this thread needs to have a new voting system, which doesn't allow people to give their maps extremely high ratings.
Like, you can say maps you like and Hugo can tally how many people said that map for the rating. (Of course this one's probably too simple.)
Nah, I think letting people rate a suggested mappack is better. I get the average of all votes and put in the OP. But for now on, people will no longer be able to vote their own mappacks. It's a drastic decision, because there are people that votes their things thinking on other mappacks (me, for example). The same applies to "Mods Guide and Rating".
Well, okay. But you should try to get some more making sence-ier ratings on mappacks. On the top of the OP you could write, "Disagree? Post your own votes below!" or something like that.

What I was thinking about with my system is that if mappacks don't get as many +1s, people who aren't immature will accept that their map isn't as great as they think. Then again, a really good map might not get played without the high rating given by another member with your system. But of course people will always disagree with each other, as evidenced above, so if you like your system that's okay.

EDIT:
You should add a section asking for the rater's progress in the map, to weigh the reviews a little more. For example, a rating from someone who played the whole thing means more than first impressions.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 21 Dec 2013, 22:24
by Superjustinbros
Name: Gravitas
Author: Willware

Mod Required: No
Complete: No

Rating: 9

viewtopic.php?f=12&t=3826
Image

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 14 Jan 2014, 03:50
by maidenTREE
This isn't related, but a bunch of mappacks got deleted from file uploading sites, not MediaFire, I mean, like Mari0Craft, that pack Sentinel made, is now gone.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 14 Jan 2014, 03:53
by alesan99
Turtley3 wrote:This isn't related, but a bunch of mappacks got deleted from file uploading sites, not MediaFire, I mean, like Mari0Craft, that pack Sentinel made, is now gone.
That's because it's a mappack from months/years ago by an inactive user that deleted their upload account thing.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 14 Jan 2014, 03:55
by maidenTREE
alesan99 wrote:
Turtley3 wrote:This isn't related, but a bunch of mappacks got deleted from file uploading sites, not MediaFire, I mean, like Mari0Craft, that pack Sentinel made, is now gone.
That's because it's a mappack from months/years ago by an inactive user that deleted their upload account thing.
Yeah, possibly I need that Mari0Craft mappack, except uploaded on a better file uploading site, like Mediafire. And I want to see everything.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 16 Jan 2014, 03:16
by Mr.Q.Marx?
Sentinel did make pretty sweet mappacks.
2012 had a lot of mappacks using the default tileset but Into the Abyss was one of the most incredible looking maps I had seen done.
I'd recommend but seeing as there is no longer a download it would be pointless.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 16 Jan 2014, 04:39
by BobTheLawyer
Mr.Q.Marx? wrote:Sentinel did make pretty sweet mappacks.
2012 had a lot of mappacks using the default tileset but Into the Abyss was one of the most incredible looking maps I had seen done.
I'd recommend but seeing as there is no longer a download it would be pointless.
Do you have a copy?

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 16 Jan 2014, 18:44
by Mr.Q.Marx?
The last one published.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/pccz5929jaz6h ... 0Abyss.zip
I've lost the mod that came with it. It was a foreground mod and a making the lasers invisible. It would be EASILY converted into Alesan99's entities mappack. I advise someone to do that.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 28 Jan 2014, 01:01
by maidenTREE
Mr.Q.Marx? wrote:The last one published.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/pccz5929jaz6h ... 0Abyss.zip
I've lost the mod that came with it. It was a foreground mod and a making the lasers invisible. It would be EASILY converted into Alesan99's entities mappack. I advise someone to do that.
Do you have a copy of Mari0Craft by Sentinel?

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 26 Feb 2014, 02:18
by HugoBDesigner
Bump! Not much, since this is a pinned thread. Anyway, I think this thread should get a small update. You know, SE is here, and I haven't seen any suggestions of SE mappacks here. As soon as someone suggests and rates one, I'll add a "SE" category. I'm also thinking on adding categories for "Alesan99's entities" and "Mari0 +Portal", since besides vanilla Mari0 these are the 2 most used mods.

I need suggestions so I can start updating here. Any?

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 26 Feb 2014, 02:24
by MissingWorld
HugoBDesigner wrote:You know, SE is here, and I haven't seen any suggestions of SE mappacks here.
Probably because there haven't been many highly recommendable SE mappacks that are released yet.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 26 Feb 2014, 02:28
by HugoBDesigner
MissingWorld wrote:
HugoBDesigner wrote:You know, SE is here, and I haven't seen any suggestions of SE mappacks here.
Probably because there haven't been many highly recommendable SE mappacks that are released yet.
Well, I and other people too posted mappacks that weren't THAT GREAT too. Example: my "Curved Science" mappack. It's a small concept mappack of only 2 worlds, but people seemed to have liked it when I published, and rated it well. So, perhaps some other small-but-cool mappacks should be highlighted a bit too.

Speaking of Curved Science, I'll update it soon to use the newest features of my mod, and probably a few more levels. Wait for that...

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 08 Mar 2014, 20:49
by HugoBDesigner
Another small bump!

I know this may sound weird, but could someone rate my Blue Portals mappack? I know, it is only the first world now, but some of you have already seen some progress of it while I showed progress on Mari0 +Portal. I'm asking it because I'm updating my blog, and I want to show others the rating of my mappacks.

Also, if you guys could too, I'd like a rate for my very first mappack here, Under Aperture. Yeah, it's not a GREAT mappack, but still...

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 08 Mar 2014, 20:51
by TurretBot
SE crashed 0/10

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 08 Mar 2014, 20:52
by HugoBDesigner
TurretBot wrote:SE crashed 0/10
Okay, good joke (not really), but seriously. Quoting so it gets visible:
HugoBDesigner wrote:Another small bump!

I know this may sound weird, but could someone rate my Blue Portals mappack? I know, it is only the first world now, but some of you have already seen some progress of it while I showed progress on Mari0 +Portal. I'm asking it because I'm updating my blog, and I want to show others the rating of my mappacks.

Also, if you guys could too, I'd like a rate for my very first mappack here, Under Aperture. Yeah, it's not a GREAT mappack, but still...

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 02 Apr 2014, 18:50
by sarge_Brain
Hey, where's my mappack?

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 02 Apr 2014, 18:56
by sarge_Brain
Name: Glad0s Woke Up
Author: sarge_Brain
Mod required: No
Progress: Being worked

Genre: Adventure
Image
Image

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 03 Apr 2014, 02:01
by MM102
Hans1998 wrote:
QwertymanO07 wrote:(Honestly, I think there should be some rule against posting your own mappacks.)
You're right!

Hey you! Yes, you! The little kid who think his map worth an "8"!
There are mappack that are better than yours and they have less rating (like Lines and Zero Blocks).
I'm not saying that your mappack is bad, but you should wait to someone to rate your map.
I think it's a "6", but i'm not good rating mappack, and i haven't played it.
Play some mappacks and then ask yourself:
"Really my mappack is as good as Abstracta, 0'Brothers or Old Apperture?"
Maybe one day your mappack will be as good as mine.

EDIT: Writing this i noticed that in my mappack says "not updated", and that's a lie.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 03 Apr 2014, 02:14
by MagicPillow
Well it's not like they gave it a very high rating...

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 14 Apr 2014, 21:41
by Smear-Gel
A separate section (or even page) for SE sounds like a good idea.

Gonna post my maps since no-one else did (but not rate them because, come on now lol.) If people could rate them that's be neat.

Name: as time g0es on...
Author: Smear-Gel
Mod required: No
Genre: Platform
Progress: Fully finished
Screenshot: Image
Link: viewtopic.php?f=12&t=2739&hilit=+as+time

Name: New Thinking with Old Portals
Author: Smear-Gel
Mod Required: No
Genre: Puzzle/Platform
Progress: Fully Finished
Screenshot: Image
Link: viewtopic.php?f=12&t=3165&hilit=+new+thinking

Ratings:

Mindache: 10 (I'm very biased to Wiiware's maps yes)
0'Brothers: 9 (it was a bit too hard near the end but the effort put into it means it deserves nothing less than a 9.)
Glitchy Error: 7 (the concept was cool but the level design lost me halfway through0
Mario Exploration: 6 (the hilarity of how dumb it is makes me ignore how dumb it is.)
Silh0uette: 9 (love the high concept awesomeness the only flaw was that there wasnt more)
The Flow of Time: 8 (This was a classic)

ALSO

WHERE IS ZETA

Wiiware please I love that map so much

Name: Zeta
Author: Wiiware
Mod required: no
Genre: Platform/Puzzle/Adventure?
Progress:NOT FINISHED AND IT MAKES ME WANT TO CRY
My rating: 10 (still probably my favourite map here. I would have rated it best mappack ever but that's a dumb rating and needs to be removed)
Screenshot: Image

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 14 Apr 2014, 23:50
by MagicPillow
I'm gonna' rate 0'Brothers 10 because it currently has a rather low rating, and, while it was difficult, it was still a great mappack with custom music, tiles, and backgrounds.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 15 Apr 2014, 00:02
by TurretBot
MagicPillow wrote:I'm gonna' rate 0'Brothers 10 because it currently has a rather low rating, and, while it was difficult, it was still a great mappack with custom music, tiles, and backgrounds.
No it was a stupid map with too many fucking shell puzzles 0/10
#sarcasm

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 15 Apr 2014, 00:48
by Smear-Gel
More like hell puzzles am I right?

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 15 Apr 2014, 01:08
by HugoBDesigner
Yeah, I also think it was low-rated, but since I MUST make the average of ratings, it is 9 now :)

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 15 Apr 2014, 05:42
by Smear-Gel
Glad to see Zeta up there, even if nothing else is updated yet.

This was actually helpful because I found the pirate map from this today and really enjoyed it.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 15 Apr 2014, 09:43
by Flutter Skye
I give 0'Brothers a 10/10 too. Even though it was hard, it was fun.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 16 Jun 2014, 14:01
by Sergione
Sorry for the bump:

Name: Mentality
Author: Sergione
Mod required: No
Progress: Being worked

Genre: Puzzle
Image
Image
In addition, Hugo, you could also put a thread for the mappack compatible with SE?

Thank you.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 16 Jun 2014, 17:03
by HugoBDesigner
Sergione wrote:Sorry for the bump:
This is a sticky thread, which stays on top always. You can "bump" it whenever you want ;)
Sergione wrote:In addition, Hugo, you could also put a thread for the mappack compatible with SE?

Thank you.
I suggested it myself once (along with mod mappacks too), but, as someone said (don't remember who and I'm too lazy to search), there aren't many mappacks for SE finished yet. Most of them are either 1 World long and experimental or unfinished or unreleased. As soon as I get some mappacks for SE I'll add those :)

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 17 Jun 2014, 23:48
by Smear-Gel
I hate that I have to ask (in more ways than one) but is there any reason none of mine are up yet? The other maps I suggested and grades I added seems to be up (at least some of them) but frustratingly, all my map packs are still absent.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 18 Jun 2014, 02:03
by HugoBDesigner
Smear-Gel wrote:I hate that I have to ask (in more ways than one) but is there any reason none of mine are up yet? The other maps I suggested and grades I added seems to be up (at least some of them) but frustratingly, all my map packs are still absent.
I add all the suggestions/ratings others ask here. I saw the post you made with two of your mappacks, but I didn't post because no one rated. But since I like you and your mappacks, I'll rate both 10, cause both are great!

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 18 Jun 2014, 02:16
by TurretBot
Maybe you could make a seperate thread for SE maps?

If you posted them here, they'd be drowned by the amount of 1.6 maps.

Re: Mappacks Guide and Rating

Posted: 18 Jun 2014, 05:05
by HugoBDesigner
I'm not gonna put them together with 1.6 maps, Turret. Therefore, then will not be "drowned"...